Something has struck me about year-end best-of lists. Fact is, most of these rankings by the so-called experts are almost gluttonously engorged, listing 50 to 100 "best albums" for this year alone! I can hardly be arsed to name my 50 best albums of all time, let alone of this year - I suppose when you get paid to listen to music, you accrue an arsenal of names to drop, but even so, that leaves the rather weighty (in my mind, at least) problem of comparison. How do you rank, say, The Arcade Fire versus Jay-Z? LCD Soundsystem versus Radiohead? Bruce Springsteen versus Animal Collective? It seems almost nonsensical, like trying to prove whether The Godfather or Eraserhead is a better movie - the two works don't even exist in the same context*.
Point is, it takes a lot of pomposity to stack a list with acts whose only point of comparison might be that they all, at a base level, do something with notes and rythyms. Rather than muck about with some unhelpful and ultimately frustrating rating scale, or pretend to have anything close to comprehensive knowledge of this year in music, I've decided merely to gush enthusiastically (and alphabetically) about the albums I found myself returning to over and over this year:
Arcade Fire - Neon BibleTrading in the apocalyptic frenzy of Funeral for post-apocalyptic dirges and jangly, anthemic folk jams, The Arcade Fire found substantial musical growth while retaining everything that made me fall in love with them in the first place. Barring a few all-too-earnest lines ("Mirror, mirror on the wall / Show me where them bombs will fall"),
Neon Bible was the most significant protest album of '07, as well as one of the most emotionally resonant. Angry as it is, "Antichrist Television Blues" (arguably the best song on the record) hints at a poignant empathy for its ugly protagonist, while "Ocean of Noise" invites us to sink into oblivion with its lying narrator. Yet amongst all this dread, hope still prevails (in staple anthems "Keep the Car Running" and "No Cars Go"). Allegedly, the band broke down in tears while recording album closer "My Body is a Cage," and it's not hard to believe - the transcendent beauty of the piece is enough to sweep you away.
Animal Collective - Strawberry JamEasily the weirdest album on this list, yet undeniably entrancing. At one point this year, a friend asked me which song off this album would be the most accessible to include on a mix CD, and I found it impossibly hard to answer. For one, accessible is probably the least apt adjective to apply to
Strawberry Jam - from the stomach-churning cover art, to the nonsensical lyrics, to the glitchy, quirky tunes to the chanting shouting yodeling vocals, it's all a bit of a whirlwind. However, when taken in its entirety, the album slowly coalesces into a beautiful experience, with swells and ebbs and a timely resonance. It is one of the most complete musical experiences released this year, and a joy to hear. (PS - I ended up going with "For Reverend Green," although "#1" was also a strong contender. If you've heard the album, you know exactly how silly that is.)
The Bees - OctopusFree the Bees was an obsession for me back in 2005, so I was anxiously awaiting The Bees' follow-up this year. I was not disappointed. While palpably darker than their previous outing,
Octopus is still firmly rooted in retro pop rock. Listening to The Bees is like a tour through the Rock 'N Roll Circus - the album opens with the consciously Beatles-esque "Who Knows What the Question Is" and steams on through "Love in the Harbour," which is a better Who song than the Who ever wrote.
Octopus assuredly has a swing in its step, bringing the funk for dance-ready "Left Foot Stepdown" and "(This is for the) Better Days." My toe is tapping just thinking about it - this is an album that will make you move.
Feist - The ReminderFeist's vocal delivery is effortlessly impeccable, evoking such beautiful emotions, it took me about two seconds to get over thinking that "Feist" was an obnoxious name. She can make you dance ("My Moon My Man"), lull you slowly and beautifully into sleep ("The Water"), break your heart ("Limit To Your Love"). "I Feel It All" is, to me, the indie-rock anthem of the year. Similar acts stick to niches - Fiona Apple has her (excellent) moody, jazzy tunes, Regina Spektor sticks mostly to (excellent) radio-friendly, slightly quirky piano ballads, but Feist has the gamut covered.
Glen Hansard & Marketa Irglova - Once SoundtrackIf there's one genre that feels much too bloatingly over-saturated, it's the sad-sounding accented man avec acoustic guitar, but somehow these songs are just too good to take to task for sentimentality - that's what lost love songs are all about, innit? Perhaps it's that Hansard finds hope among the despair, in lines like "You have suffered enough / and warred with yourself / it's time that you won," or perhaps it's the elegant harmonies of co-vocalist Irglova - like in the film, Hansard and Irglova's chemistry with each other is fascinating. It's true that the songs are given even greater resonance in context with the (excellent!) film, but so many of these are such instant classics ("Falling Slowly," "If You Want Me," "When Your Mind's Made Up," etc). Cheers to them for including the hilarious throw-off "Broken Hearted Hoover Fixer Sucker Guy."
Jens Lekman - Night Falls Over KorteladaIf Sufjan Stevens wrote epic, anthemic 60's pop tunes instead of epic, anthemic folk tunes, and also if he had a Swedish accent, he'd be Jens Lekman. Far from simple love songs, Lekman's tunes have a deeper scope and a surprising sense of humor. Where "Sipping On the Sweet Nectar" laments the loss of love and good times, "Shirin" tells the tale of a beautiful Iraqi refugee who runs an illegal beauty salon in her apartment. Lekman's tales are vibrant touching, and his music strangely fresh - even if it does make you want to dance the disco.
LCD Soundsystem - Sound of SilverSpeaking of dancing. What more need be said?
Sound of Silver is the album to shake your booty to. And yet, so much more must be said - while "Get Innocuous!" will make you feel like the ultimate badass, LCD Soundsystem is layers deeper than your standard club fare. Hypnotic gems like "Someone Great" and "All My Friends" hide mature, contemplative lyrics that explore the loss of, well, someone great, and lament getting caught up in the race (strangely applicable to my life: "You spent the first five years trying to get with the plan, / and the next five years trying to be with your friends again"). Let it not be said that singer/songwriter/producer James Murphy has no sense of humor, however - "North American Scum" is both arrogant and acerbically tongue-in-cheek, and "New York, I Love You But You're Bringing Me Down" speaks for itself. The real star here, however, is the way the music subtly grows, deftly arranging loops and beats that would be repetitive in lesser hands, and building and building to critical mass before resolving elegantly.
Menomena - Friend and FoeHere is an album of absolute beauty, at times both dense and stark, with divine harmonies, thumping basslines, glitchy drums, orchestrated guitars, moody pianos and sing-along lyrics. When "I Am The Fun Blame Monster" came out years ago, I knew I liked Menomena a lot, but who could have predicted the massive steps they would take to their second album? The trio morphed from an atmospheric, brooding electronic act into a full-blown rock band with shrieks and whispers, choirs and crashes. It's an album that's crafted, every piece singularly and yet imperceptibly placed. The dark jam "The Pelican" stutters into the delicate nudgings of "Wet and Rusting." "Weird" thrashes its way into the chill-out groove of "Rotten Hell." It's the most organic album I've heard in years, and considering it was made mostly with computers, that's something to say.
The National - BoxerAside from one or two songs,
Boxer is mostly a restrained exercise in toned-down beauty, full of low-key ballads with crooning vocals that will steal your heart away. It's the perfect late-night album - dark and delicate, with moments of understated beauty. "Slow Show" is, for my money, the love song of the year. (Take that, "Umbrella"!)
Of Montreal - Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?"Frenetic" is the best word I can think of to describe Of Montreal. "Hissing Fauna..." is certainly frenetic, not even pausing for breath between track after energetic track. Sometimes the band doesn't even wait for the track to change to start playing a new tune (with the notable exception of "The Past is a Grotesque Animal," which goes on and on and on, although curiously you never want it to stop). Filled with infectiously poppy tunes and lyrics that border on just a little too quirky, this album is wildly original. My favorite tune is "Gronlandic Edit," which sounds a bit like Queen teaming up with a funk band, although the Beck-ish "Faberge Falls for Shuggie" is undeniable fun. Lead singer/songwriter Kevin Barnes has a sense for the operatic ADD pop song.
Radiohead - In RainbowsWhen a band has already revolutionized the way you think about music twice, it can be unreasonably hard not to develop unfair expectations on the eve of a new album, especially when said album has just revolutionized the way you think about buying music. But when all the hubbub about the self-pricing died down, the album we all downloaded turned out to be a surprise after all. It's true that Radiohead (or any other band, for that matter) will probably never deliver an album with the effect of
OK Computer or
Kid A again, but what they have delivered in
In Rainbows is their most beautiful and timeless album. Warmth permeates the record, from the blazing rocker "Bodysnatchers" to the sultry "All I Need." From the meandering melody of "Nude" to the golden placement of the titular line in "Reckoner,"
In Rainbows is more than just a rock album, it's a rock work of art. (And it sounds even better in vinyl!)
Spoon - Ga Ga Ga Ga GaI am convinced that Spoon's last four albums are perfect. These guys are masters of pop rock, growing while simultaneously shedding - "The Ghost of You Lingers" is both the sparest and best song they've ever written. However, even with their bones showing, they've never jettisoned what makes them good - the fun, the attitude, the method and the bounce behind their songwriting. The addition of an occasional horn section could have been unbearably cheesy, but suddenly I can't imagine hearing Spoon without the horns. It doesn't hurt that Britt Daniels has the best voice in rock, either.
Various Artists - I'm Not There SoundtrackThe movie had a high reach - perhaps too impossibly high - but was entirely too uneven. The soundtrack doesn't have the same problem - even with the occasional uninspiring track, so much of this is so good, it's silly. But that's what happens when you get some of today's best artists covering one of the greatest songwriters. Cover albums are inevitably hindered by unoriginality - the general rule is that if I want to hear a song played exactly the same way it was originally written, I'll listen to the people who wrote it. Yet even when the artists follow Dylan's lead to the T, the album never drags or feels contrived. It's a testament to the timelessness of Dylan's songs, and the talent of the performers.
Next time I'll talk about a few of the albums that didn't make the cut and why, and also a few albums from the past I've only just discovered.
* That won't stop me from making a top ten 2007 movies, though! I've got a degree in it, suckas!